If you’ve stopped trying, there was probably a reason
Before giving up, there’s usually a certain type of exhaustion that comes up.
If you’ve found yourself thinking I’ve given up trying to make friends as an adult, the chances are you didn’t arrive there without trying first. You reached out and the message went unanswered. You joined the class, or the club, or the running group, and six weeks later you were still a stranger to everyone in it. You had the coffee that felt promising and then it simply never became anything. You did the things you were supposed to do, and they didn’t work, and at some point the cost of trying started to outweigh the thin and unreliable reward.
This doesn’t mean anything is wrong with you, it simply means you don’t have the full picture.
How common is this
This is more common than almost anyone admits. The research is fairly bleak:
-
- 17% of American adults report having no close friends at all — AEI Survey Centre, 2024
-
- 57% describe themselves as lonely — Cigna/Evernorth, 2024
-
- Adults aged 30 to 44 are the loneliest demographic in the country, with 29% reporting frequent loneliness — Harvard Making Caring Common, 2023
-
- The share of Americans with ten or more close friends has fallen from 33% in 1990 to just 13% in 2021
This is a huge majority of people who are lonely. You aren’t alone in this. Just walk down the street and you will likely see someone who is lonelier than you think.
Why the standard advice doesn’t work
The usual suggestions, like joining a club, are not wrong exactly, but they leave out the most important part. They describe how to put yourself in the same room as other people. They say nothing about what converts proximity into friendship.
Most people haven’t been taught how to convert that proximity into friendship, as the environment around them did it for them. Adult life removes those structures and replaces them with nothing. And then the advice is to join a pottery class.
The reason making friends after feels so much harder is because the natural environment that used to produce friendship is now gone, and you haven’t been taught how to replace it.
What actually moves things forward
1. The problem is usually targeting, not effort
When people who’ve given up on adult friendships describe what they tried, the pattern I see most often isn’t insufficient effort, but effort directed at the wrong people.
Specifically: reaching out to people who haven’t shown warmth, on the basis that they seem compatible. Same interests, same life stage, similar values on paper. But warmth matters more than compatibility in the early stages. A warm contact who seems less obviously ‘your type’ will convert into a friendship faster than a cold one who seems perfect.
Before anything else, think about who has shown genuine warmth recently. Someone who seemed pleased to see you the last time they did, or who responded to a message recently. Most people overlook those people entirely while pursuing ones who look better on paper.
2. One recurring structure is worth more than ten one-off plans
One-off plans are exhausting to organise and fragile when they don’t materialise. A recurring structure removes most of that friction.
‘I go to that park run most Saturday mornings, you should come along sometime, I’ll let you know when I’m going next.’ This is perfect because it is a repeated activity that you are already engaging in, whether or not somebody goes.
Repeated contact over time is the thing to aim for, especially if it’s in a low stakes environment.
-
- Attach it to something you already do — the gym, the weekly market, the dog walk
-
- Make it genuinely optional for them, so they never feel the weight of obligation
-
- Propose it at the end of a meeting that went well, when the warmth is still present
3. The follow-up is the thing most people skip
The most reliable way to let a promising early-stage connection expire is to not follow up. If you let the early-stage connection fade away to time without doing anything about it, you won’t be able to forge any meaningful relationships.
A follow-up that works is short, specific, and doesn’t ask for anything. Within seventy-two hours reference something real from the conversation, add a small observation, and close it without demanding a response. This is often the entire difference between a connection that becomes a friendship and one that quietly disappears.
4. Depth doesn’t happen by accident
Surface-level connection is easy to sustain indefinitely. You can have pleasant, perfectly agreeable conversations with the same person for two years and still feel like strangers. Warmth without depth isn’t friendship; it’s a long acquaintance.
Moving deeper requires one person to go slightly further than the conversation demands. It can just be a small observation that makes the conversation a little deeper than it was before, without necessarily needing deep confessions or an account of personal history.
The mechanism is called self-disclosure reciprocity, which is when one person goes slightly deeper, the other tends to follow at roughly the same level. It escalates incrementally, in small steps, without either person feeling exposed. Someone has to go first though, so try and make sure it is you.
There’s more to this than four strategies
The four strategies above will help move things forward. But if you’ve been dealing with the issue of loneliness for a while, or if you’re returning to this after previous attempts that didn’t work, there are deeper layers to this problem that a blog post doesn’t have room for.
I spent a long time researching this and I ended up writing a complete guide. I didn’t plan for it to be long, but ended up writing something over 10,000 words long, deciding that depth was what the topic needed.
The guide covers, among other things:
-
- How to build depth in a relationship, including scripts to initiate the first contact
-
- What to do when you have tried and failed before, and how to not let that stop you
-
- How to show up for someone when they are going through good and bad times (which is key to a long lasting friendship)
-
- A maintenance system for ensuring you can keep the friendships you have spent a long time trying to create
It’s available here for $24 and covers the whole problem with direct and actionable steps.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it normal to have no close friends as an adult?
Completely normal, and more common than most people realise. Research consistently shows that adult friendlessness is a widespread experience. The AEI Survey Centre found that 17% of American adults have no close friends at all; broader loneliness surveys put the figure for frequent loneliness somewhere between 29% and 57% depending on how the question is framed. You are not an outlier.
How do you make friends as an adult without it seeming desperate?
Specificity is the most important thing, as vague requests can sound needy and desperate. Always make sure to include days, times and places when making plans with others.
Why is making friends as an adult so much harder than when you were younger?
Because the usual structures, like school, where sharing a classroom with other people made it easy for you to make friends, no longer exist in your life. This means that you need to relearn how to do these things yourself, without the built-in structures.
What do you do when you’ve tried making friends and it hasn’t worked?
If you’ve only been trying for a short while, say, a few months, I’d first recommend just keeping at it. Friendships usually take longer than a few months to form, so waiting can be a good first step. It’s also worth thinking about how often you are seeing these people. If it’s irregular (less than three times a month), then it’s very unlikely that a friendship will be formed in that time.
How long does it actually take to make friends as an adult?
Research by psychologist Jeffrey Hall suggests it takes roughly fifty hours of time together to move from acquaintance to casual friend, and around two hundred hours for a close friendship. It may sound like a lot, but if you meet with somebody weekly, that timeframe becomes a lot more manageable.
The Social Rebuild publishes honest writing about friendship and loneliness. It takes my personal experiences and in depth research from valid institutions to help guide people to creating connections in their lives again.